IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision
kodonnell1
Posted 2009-12-02 11:31 AM (#48931)
Subject: IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision


Tourer

Posts: 460
Hello All
I was wondering if the MP-3 Quality sound was better than the XM Satelite sound through the factory speakers on the 09 Vision Premium . Another question - Is the reception on the XM unit top notch or will it be going out on me all the time, and what model works with the 09 vision.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
Big Vic
Posted 2009-12-02 6:22 PM (#48966 - in reply to #48931)
Subject: Re: IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision


Iron Butt

Posts: 619
Southeast Iowa
On my bike the ipod sounds much better than the XM. I never knew my speakers could sound so good until I joined the ipod generation. Not sure this makes sense but that's how it is on my bike. As far as reception, I don't have any issues unless I'm riding real close to a bluff or dense wooded area. By the way..............XM will deal on their price! I only had to tell them I was not going to renew my subscription when they offered to cut my price by 1/2.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
bigwill5150
Posted 2009-12-02 7:20 PM (#48974 - in reply to #48931)
Subject: Re: IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision


Iron Butt

Posts: 725
Reno County, KS
Thanks for the tip Big Vic. I'll try to haggle with Sirius next time I renew. Being that I have 3 receivers with Sirius for years now, they may decide to cut me a break.
Top of the page Bottom of the page
TimS
Posted 2009-12-02 8:16 PM (#48979 - in reply to #48931)
Subject: RE: IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision


Iron Butt

Posts: 810

XM broadcasts compress dynamic range on audio as well as uses lossy bitrate compression.  Both of these degrade the sound of the XM audio.

Depending on how you rip your music, you can make your IPOD sound MUCH BETTER, the same or worse than XM. 

I usually rip my IPOD music using a lossless compression (except for recorded audio books) and it sounds much better than XM on the Vision.

HTH,

Tim



Edited by TimS 2009-12-02 8:19 PM
Top of the page Bottom of the page
#57
Posted 2009-12-02 10:25 PM (#48988 - in reply to #48931)
Subject: Re: IPod Quality Vs. XM Quality Sound On The 09 Vision


Tourer

Posts: 415
Wow, I have no idea what I just read.
That being said, I use my Ipod all the time.
XM in my riding area gets very sketchy. Lots of hills and tree lined roads.
Will most likely not renew. My FM radio comes in better than XM.
Top of the page Bottom of the page